Armed conflict throughout the 80’s deepened the economic crisis and led to an economic recession, lasting from 1981 to 1986, during which GDP fell annually by almost 1%. The greatest impact of these crises and subsequent economic stagnation has been the increase in poverty and inequality in rural areas, above all amongst indigenous communities. The lack of coordination between Government and the Municipalities in the affected areas meant that responsibility for providing basic public services and the construction and maintenance of infrastructure was ignored, and some areas of the country were largely neglected by the state. This polarization of the country contributed to a tendency whereby the meagre social investment that existed was focussed on territories where there was the least conflict and those suffering conditions of greatest poverty and isolation were overlooked.
All of this, when added to racism and a culture of indigenous exclusion, has brought about a situation where some regions of the country, such as the Rio Naranjo basin in the Mam Region, have become a prime example of social exclusion. Situated on the border with Mexico, it has a population of around 400,000 inhabitants, more than 50% of whom are poor and 30% live in extreme poverty. The indigenous population represents approximately 80% of the total and more than 45% suffer extreme poverty. The Mam Indigenous People who inhabit the area have some of the lowest human development indices: 0.496 (as opposed to 0.64 for the whole country and 0.83 in the capital), with those for health at 0.541, education at 0.428 and income at 0.518.
The majority of its communities are made up of workers from the informal economy and landless peasants, who migrate with their wives and family at harvest times from the highlands to the south coast, which makes them particularly vulnerable. Conditions of exclusion from access to basic public services give rise to very poor health indicators, which in turn have a bearing on the scarce attention afforded to women’s sexual and reproductive health needs. The region stands out as one of the most vulnerable regarding drinking water and sanitation. More than 200,000 people have no access to a safe water supply or basic sanitation. These deficiencies translate into poverty and precarious health conditions for the population living in the rural and peri-urban areas: 4 out of every 10 inhabitants annually suffer from diseases caused by water contamination, inadequate sanitation and poor hygiene practices. Gastrointestinal diseases caused by water and food contamination are the second greatest cause of general mortality, to which may be added those related to irregular and inadequate distribution and deficient health and hygiene conditions, such as skin complaints, dengue fever, and other infections, which are at the heart of malnutrition and poor food safety, and subsequent human under-development.
This situation has repercussions on the present and future productivity of the population. The time invested in gathering, transporting and supplying water to homes is one of the factors that explain the gender gap reflected in school absence. In villages where there is no water supply in the home or nearby, it is usual for children, especially young girls, to fetch water, a task that can take them up to three or four hours, time equivalent to an average schoolday. Another example is that most of the schools in rural areas lack individual water and sanitation facilities for young girls, a factor that inhibits them from attending or even going to school, since culturally they do not feel free or at ease to use them. If, in addition, these services are inadequate or non-existent, then the schools become a focus for the transmission of gastrointestinal infections. And when added to the fact that conditions in the home are also inadequate and water is unsafe, gastrointestinal diseases are one of the principal causes of non-attendance and even giving up school altogether.
According to the 2006 UNDP Human Development Report, the educational disparities caused by a lack of water and sanitation facilities have a lifelong impact that is transmitted from generation to generation, and the Second Report on Fulfillment of the Millennium Goals in Guatemala (2006) warns of the seriousness of this issue for the country, concluding that the lack of basic water and sanitation facilities is closely associated with malnutrition and maternal and infant mortality. The report estimates that an increase of 10% of homes with adequate services of drinking water could reduce infant malnutrition by 8.2%.
The Mam Region of Río Naranjo is situated in Guatemala’s volcano belt at the head of the river basin, with mountain soils characterized by steep slopes and sheer cliffs, with valleys, planes and uplands rising from 1,600 masl to more than 3,000 masl. It comprises the municipalities of: San Marcos, San Pedro, San Antonio, San Cristóbal Cucho and Esquipulas Palo Gordo, in the District of San Marcos, and those of Palestina de los Altos, San Juan Ostuncalco and San Martín in Quetzaltenango. All of these are organized into a Mancomunidad (Grouping of Associated Municipalities) entitled MANCUERNA. This organization represents a significant advance demonstrating a political will on the part of local authorities to work together in pooling their strengths and resources. They share a Strategic Development Plan and Water policy, but their activities are nascent and require technical and financial support. The area produces annual below-subsistence crops of maize and, to a lesser extent, wheat and vegetables, taking up 13% of the total catchment area, but this is where the largest part of the land surface is covered by conifer forests, representing 21% of the total area. There is also soil erosion and leeching of nutrients due to agricultural practices in areas unsuitable for cultivation, exacerbated by excess humidity and/or prolonged periods of rain (water erosion).
The principal threats relating to water management due to human activity are the felling of natural forests and their structural degradation, the application of traditional methods of hillside cultivation without the appropriate techniques, the reduction of ground and surface water sources putting water supplies at risk (technically these can be considered to be exhausted, taking into account the slopes, population and conflicts of use) and the contamination of water resources by waste water, solid waste and chemicals. The causes of deterioration in water quality, in addition to contamination by sediments, pesticides and honey waters, is the lack of treatment of domestic waste water in most villages and the inadequate collection, treatment and final disposal of rubbish. The natural phenomenon of Tropical Storm Stan highlighted the extreme vulnerability of poor and extremely poor rural families. The precariousness of life for these families meant that they lost their farming plots and vegetable gardens which represented a source of food diversity. This has hindered and slowed development, with a drastic reduction in the availability of food for home-consumption and the loss of productive assets.
Government Policies
Within the framework of the “Firm and Lasting Peace Agreements” of 1996, ILO Convention No. 169 and the Millennium Declaration, the State initiated a transformation of public policy, prioritizing the reduction of poverty and promotion of rural development. Since 2002, it has promoted a process of economic and administrative decentralization, implemented through the Ley de Consejos de Desarrollo (Development Councils Law, Decree 11-2002), the Ley General de Descentralización (General Law on Decentralization, Decree 14-2002) and the Código Municipal (Municipal Law, Decree 12-2002), which establish a structure for the formulation, implementation and assessment of public policies, whereby: a) the central Government transfers the functions of developmental planning to the Municipalities, which already had competence for regulating services, b) the System of Local Councils serves as the framework for participatory planning, social auditing, transparency and good governance, especially at the level of Municipal Development Councils – COMUDEs – and c) encourages the grouping together of Municipalities in order to build their management and implementation capacities, by freely forming “Groupings”, which will allow them to achieve better territorial coordination and economies of scale in their joint projects.
At local level, this “decentralized administration” requires an immense effort in order to make it more operationally effective. In the medium term, three aspects have been identified that need to be worked upon in order to bolster the System: a) linking participatory planning to the process of local budgetary allocation, b) forming political and social covenants, in which civil society and the Government assume joint responsibility for integrated water management (sources, use and treatment) with an emphasis on systems for supplying drinking water and sanitation, as well as water for irrigation, and c) achieving greater and improved participation on the part of the people, especially women (it should be mentioned that their participation in the areas of local decision making has not increased and continues at levels of no more than 2%). Adopting these aspects as its starting point, the Programme is aimed towards strengthening the processes initiated in the COMUDEs, in order to encourage citizen participation and social auditing in the negotiation, design and implementation of projects and in the provision of basic public services to the area of influence of the Río Naranjo Municipal Grouping, MANCUERNA, as well as to achieve good governance in their delivery.
The United Nations System (UNS)
The Programme is included within the strategy of the United Nations System, seeking to accelerate the achievements of the MDGs for indigenous peoples. In particular, it aims to have a direct impact on improving maternal and infant health (MDG4 and MDG5) amongst the Mam people, promoting access to safe drinking water and sanitation (MDG7), and the productive use of water in the eradication of extreme poverty and hunger (MDG1), as well as having a bearing on the promotion of gender equality and women’s autonomy (MDG3). Within the Development Assistance Framework (UNDAF), the Programme supports the local indigenous population’s right to effective social and political participation, along with cultural relevance, gender perspective and the elimination of discrimination in areas of dialogue between Government and Civil Society, in order to have an influence on increasing the range, access and quality of basic public services for water and sanitation, as well as encouraging their own human development.